Monday, October 2, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • E-edition
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • News
  • Economy
  • E-Edition
  • Columns
  • Companies & Markets
  • In Business With
  • Lifestyle
    • Motoring
  • Sports
    Tumisang Orebonye: Overcoming Against Adversity to Reach for the Stars

    ‘Winning The CAF Super Cup Is A Dream Come True’ – Orebonye

    BAA Needs Over P3m For World Champs

    Botswana’s Sporting Future in Jeopardy: School Sports Suspension Threatens Athletic Excellence

    No House For Tebogo Despite Astral Performance in Budapest

    “No Pressure for Tebogo at Diamond League Finals”

    BOKA Aims to Host Two Prestigious International Karate Competitions

    BOKA Aims to Host Two Prestigious International Karate Competitions

    FM Botswana 2022 conference: transformation towards a greener FM 

    StanChart CEO Underscores Role of UB Marathon in Boosting Botswana’s Sports Tourism

    No House For Tebogo Despite Astral Performance in Budapest

    No House For Tebogo Despite Astral Performance in Budapest

    Trending Tags

    • Subscribe
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • News
    • Economy
    • E-Edition
    • Columns
    • Companies & Markets
    • In Business With
    • Lifestyle
      • Motoring
    • Sports
      Tumisang Orebonye: Overcoming Against Adversity to Reach for the Stars

      ‘Winning The CAF Super Cup Is A Dream Come True’ – Orebonye

      BAA Needs Over P3m For World Champs

      Botswana’s Sporting Future in Jeopardy: School Sports Suspension Threatens Athletic Excellence

      No House For Tebogo Despite Astral Performance in Budapest

      “No Pressure for Tebogo at Diamond League Finals”

      BOKA Aims to Host Two Prestigious International Karate Competitions

      BOKA Aims to Host Two Prestigious International Karate Competitions

      FM Botswana 2022 conference: transformation towards a greener FM 

      StanChart CEO Underscores Role of UB Marathon in Boosting Botswana’s Sports Tourism

      No House For Tebogo Despite Astral Performance in Budapest

      No House For Tebogo Despite Astral Performance in Budapest

      Trending Tags

      • Subscribe
      No Result
      View All Result
      The Business Weekly & Review
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Columns Tax & Your Pockets

      Fabricated transactions are tax risky

      Generally, the substance over form principle ensures that the actual economic reality of any transaction takes precedence over any form in which the transaction is crafted or implemented.

      mm by Jonathan Hore & Gavin Mashiri Jonathan Hore & Gavin Mashiri
      July 21, 2022
      in Tax & Your Pockets
      Reading Time: 3 mins read
      0
      Fabricated transactions are tax risky
      Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

      In some cases, businesses enter into various trade agreements that require legal documents such as contracts, partnership deeds etc.

      Mostly, such documents usually detail the terms and conditions which generally informs the arrangement of the transactions. However, due to changes in tax laws such legal documents may end up not being aligned to the provisions of the tax laws, thereby not giving an accurate image of the true transaction on hand.

      On the other hand, legal documentation may actually be crafted in a way that hides the true nature of transactions. Consequently, such transactions may result in taxpayers inadvertently failing to pay tax which may trigger penalties in case of a tax audit. It is therefore imperative that taxpayers consider the substance of the transaction when making critical decisions to avoid any arising penalties. Keep on reading and allow us to help you understand the importance of the substance over form principle in making crucial business decisions. In this article, words importing the masculine shall be deemed to include the feminine.

      Substance over form

      Generally, the substance over form principle ensures that the actual economic reality of any transaction takes precedence over any form in which the transaction is crafted or implemented. The principle is used in a wide range of situations including financial reporting. The said principle is adopted to ensure that entities provide an accurate and complete overview of their events and transactions to their stake holders. Accordingly, this allows priority consideration to be given to the economic impact of a transaction instead of its legal form, which could conceivably mislead people on its true intent. Simply put, the economic reality of a transaction denotes the substance whereas, the legal reality denotes the form. Hence, the courts of law as well as BURS considers the substance over form in tax matters.

      Why the substance?

      As alluded to above, giving priority regard to the legal or actual form that the actual economic impact of a transaction or agreement may actually mislead stakeholders of any transactions including tax authorities. Therefore, the said principle allows BURS to ignore an arrangement’s legal form and examine its actual substance, with the goal of preventing artificial structures from being used to avoid paying taxes. Based on this analogy, it is crucial for businesses and individuals to ensure that they consider the economic reality when venturing into business deals or new transactions or arrangements before a decision is made.

      In most circumstances, tax authorities adopt the substance over form principle to restrict taxpayers from designing transactions on paper that result in an undue tax gain. As an example, Tiro a tax consultant may offer monthly tax services of P11,000 to his landlord and thereafter arrange to offset with his monthly rent of P10,000. Tiro will then have a lease that requires him to pay P1,000 to his landlord and deduct rent withholding tax of P50 instead of P500 (P10,000*5%). As you can see the economic reality is that Tiro is paying rent of P10,000 and liable to pay withholding tax of P500. However, the legal form states that Tiro is supposed to pay P1,000 and deduct P50 withholding tax resulting in gross underpayment of tax. Consequently, a tax audit may unearth such an arrangement resulting in penalties for both Tiro and his landlord.

      Conclusion

      Essentially, the substance over form is a key principle that should be applied in business arrangements. Relying entirely on legal documents may mislead decision makers which may result in additional taxes and penalties.

      Well folks, we hope that was insightful. As us the two Yours Truly say goodbye, remember to pay to Caesar what belongs to him. If you want to consult, join our free Tax WhatsApp group or to know about our 9 Tax e-books, send us a text on the cell number below. You can read more tax articles on our website, www.aupracontax.co.bw under the ‘Tax articles’ tab.

      Tags: BURS

      Navigation

      • Home
      • News
      • Economy
      • E-Edition
      • Columns
      • Companies & Markets
      • In Business With
      • Lifestyle
        • Motoring
      • Sports
      • Subscribe

      Recent News

      • September 29th Edition
      • FUEL: The Vexing – and Recurring – Question of Security of Supply
      • Hands off Bank of Botswana, IMF Tells Govt
      • BIUST holds 8th Graduation
      • StanChart leverages on its unique position

      Site

      • About
      • Advertise
      • Privacy Policy
      • Cookie Policy
      • Contact
      • Subscribe
      • E-edition

      © 2021 The Business Weekly & Review. All Rights Reserved.

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • News
      • Economy
      • E-Edition
      • Columns
      • Companies & Markets
      • In Business With
      • Lifestyle
        • Motoring
      • Sports
      • Subscribe

      © 2021 The Business Weekly & Review. All Rights Reserved.

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password? Sign Up

      Create New Account!

      Fill the forms below to register

      All fields are required. Log In

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
      Are you sure want to unlock this post?
      Unlock left : 0
      Are you sure want to cancel subscription?