Friday, March 31, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • E-edition
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • News
  • Economy
  • Columns
  • Companies & Markets
  • In Business With
  • Lifestyle
    • Motoring
  • Sports
    Botswana’s women boxing on the rise 

    Boxers Finally Receive their Prize Money from 2022 African Championships

    Darts Expects Only P50K from BNSC for 2023/24

    Darts Expects Only P50K from BNSC for 2023/24

    Botswana athletes to train in USA

    Botswana athletes to train in USA

    Debswana’s BAA Sponsorship Plays Critical Role in Developing BW Athletics – Theetso

    Debswana’s BAA Sponsorship Plays Critical Role in Developing BW Athletics – Theetso

    Boxers yet to Receive Prizes from 2022 African Boxing Championships 

    Boxers yet to Receive Prizes from 2022 African Boxing Championships 

    April will see 2nd Instalment of Summer Kids Marathon

    April will see 2nd Instalment of Summer Kids Marathon

    Trending Tags

    • Subscribe
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • News
    • Economy
    • Columns
    • Companies & Markets
    • In Business With
    • Lifestyle
      • Motoring
    • Sports
      Botswana’s women boxing on the rise 

      Boxers Finally Receive their Prize Money from 2022 African Championships

      Darts Expects Only P50K from BNSC for 2023/24

      Darts Expects Only P50K from BNSC for 2023/24

      Botswana athletes to train in USA

      Botswana athletes to train in USA

      Debswana’s BAA Sponsorship Plays Critical Role in Developing BW Athletics – Theetso

      Debswana’s BAA Sponsorship Plays Critical Role in Developing BW Athletics – Theetso

      Boxers yet to Receive Prizes from 2022 African Boxing Championships 

      Boxers yet to Receive Prizes from 2022 African Boxing Championships 

      April will see 2nd Instalment of Summer Kids Marathon

      April will see 2nd Instalment of Summer Kids Marathon

      Trending Tags

      • Subscribe
      No Result
      View All Result
      The Business Weekly & Review
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home News

      KBL CHALLENGES MASISI’S SOE POWERS

      The legal grounds made by KBL in its decision that challenges President Masisi’s SOE powers and his decision to ban the sale of liquor is that his decision was illegal, lacks substance and is grossly “absurd.”

      mm by Kabo Ramasia
      October 6, 2021
      in News
      Reading Time: 3 mins read
      0
      KBL CHALLENGES MASISI’S SOE POWERS

      President Dr Mokgweetsi Masisi left for Mozambique on 21 June 2021. Masisi will participate at the official opening of the SADC Humanitarian and Emergency Operations Center in Nacala, Mozambique. He will also participate at the Extraordinary Summit of SADC Heads of State and Goverment in Maputo. Botswana Vice President Slumber Tsogwane was at the Sir Seretse Khama International airport to bid farewell to Masisi. (Pic:Monirul Bhuiyan/PRESS PHOTO)

      Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

      Kgalagadi Breweries Limited (KBL) has filed an expedited appeal challenging President Mokgweetsi Masisi’s decision to suspend the sale of alcohol, The Business Weekly & Review has established.

      The colossal beer brewer says Masisi’s decision is irrational and lacks substance.

      In its court papers filed before the Court of Appeal on the 16th August 2021, KBL says the matter at hand is of massive public interest and involves the lawfulness of the exercise of power by the Executive including the President regulating citizens’ conduct during the State of Public Emergency (SOE) declared in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

      KBL avers that the declaration of the SOE by the President has affected the lives of every citizen in Botswana.

      “These regulations have impacted not only the lives of citizens, but also their legal rights, both under the Constitution and the common law,” says KBL.

      According to the brewer, a Government Notice dated 28 June 2021 (GN362 of 2021) was issued according to Emergency Powers(COVID-19) Regulations 2020 which was in turn promulgated under the Emergency Powers Act 9CAP 22:04) (EPA).

      KBL states that legal advice proffered to them was that the decision on the “ban on the sale of liquor” was unlawful.

      “Under the legal advice KBL received following the notice, it was advised that the decision to ban liquor sales throughout Botswana was not a lawful exercise of power and that an urgent application could be directed to the High Court for an order declaring this decision unlawful and invalid, and reviewing and setting aside Government Notice 362 of 2021,” states KBL.

      In the court papers seen by The Business Weekly & Review, KBL says it advanced several grounds for review as guided by “administrative law.”

      The St Louis beer maker asserts that it advanced grounds that the ban issued on the 28 June 2021 was not within the limits of authority provided by the EPA and regulations.

      The firm holds the view that power was exercised by the wrong official being the President (Masisi) rather than the Director of Health Services as the President is authorised to advise than take the decision.

      The second reason advanced by KBL is that President Masisi’s decision “is irrational in the sense that it is not based on any cogent or objectively verifiable evidence or facts which established a causal connection between the reduction of COVID-19 cases and consumption of alcohol, (contrary to the unsubstantiated allegations made by His Excellency, the President, that the decision was based on medical or scientific evidence),” asserts KBL in the papers.

      To compound this logic, the company argues that the decision is grossly unreasonable because it disproportionately and needlessly “affects the rights (including constitutional rights” of KBL and its employees.

      The liquor trader posits that the ban has an impact on several constitutional rights as provided by the Constitution of Botswana at section 8 (deprivation of property), and indirectly in Botswana’s obligations to respect individual dignity and the right to work which is provided by international treaties and other instruments the government is forced to uphold.

      Furthermore, it says following the decision to impose the ban, through its lawyers’ Minchin & Kelly, KBL wrote a letter to the Attorney General (AG) advancing its argument regarding the unlawful ban and requested for it to be uplifted but the efforts were unsuccessful.

      Subsequent to the failed efforts to engage the AG, as per the court papers, KBL proceeded to file an urgent application at the High Court seeking an order for the decision to be reviewed and set aside, and pending the determination of their sought relief. KBL states that an order was also sought to suspend the operation of the Government Notice/ ordering that it be suspended.

      However, despite being a matter of public interest, KBL reveals that the matter on grounds for urgency was argued on the 03 August 2021 where a panel of three judges ruled in favour of the respondents (Attorney General, President and Director of Health Services).

      Consequently, the brewer holds that the court order given in favour of government has a bearing on its rights to be protected from the unlawful exercise of power through imposing the ban.

      In addition, it notes that barring KBL or its employees from urgent access to the courts will prejudice and cause irreparable harm to them.

      Another reason they cite is that the matter is of exceptional public interest and there should be judicial considerations for the party’s rights more so that it’s an issue that deals with constitutional rights as enshrined in the Constitution.

      KBL further adds that the judgement arrived at by the courts is incorrect as the court “has significantly misdirected itself and failed to apply its discretion judicially”

      Tags: KBLSOE

      Navigation

      • Home
      • News
      • Economy
      • Columns
      • Companies & Markets
      • In Business With
      • Lifestyle
        • Motoring
      • Sports
      • Subscribe

      Recent News

      • March 30th Edition
      • The botched ‘rip off’
      • Grit cashes P200m from Letlole
      • March 24th Edition
      • March 17th Edition

      Site

      • About
      • Advertise
      • Privacy Policy
      • Cookie Policy
      • Contact
      • Subscribe
      • E-edition

      © 2021 The Business Weekly & Review. All Rights Reserved.

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • News
      • Economy
      • Columns
      • Companies & Markets
      • In Business With
      • Lifestyle
        • Motoring
      • Sports
      • Subscribe

      © 2021 The Business Weekly & Review. All Rights Reserved.

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password? Sign Up

      Create New Account!

      Fill the forms below to register

      All fields are required. Log In

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
      Are you sure want to unlock this post?
      Unlock left : 0
      Are you sure want to cancel subscription?