Sunday, January 29, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • E-edition
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • News
  • Economy
  • Columns
  • Companies & Markets
  • In Business With
  • Lifestyle
    • Motoring
  • Sports
    Debswana sponsors BFA’s National First Division League with P3.9m 

    Debswana sponsors BFA’s National First Division League with P3.9m 

    Ditlhokwe Tipped to Excel at Kaizer Chiefs

    Ditlhokwe Tipped to Excel at Kaizer Chiefs

    BCF Aims to Resuscitate Chess this Year

    BCF Aims to Resuscitate Chess this Year

    Tebogo’s Move to US on Hold

    “Don’t Panic,” Tebogo is advised as He Transits to Senior Level

    NSAs decry Absence of School Sports 

    NSAs decry Absence of School Sports 

    BCF fails to send Team to Continental Schools Chess Champs

    BCF fails to send Team to Continental Schools Chess Champs

    Trending Tags

    • Subscribe
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • News
    • Economy
    • Columns
    • Companies & Markets
    • In Business With
    • Lifestyle
      • Motoring
    • Sports
      Debswana sponsors BFA’s National First Division League with P3.9m 

      Debswana sponsors BFA’s National First Division League with P3.9m 

      Ditlhokwe Tipped to Excel at Kaizer Chiefs

      Ditlhokwe Tipped to Excel at Kaizer Chiefs

      BCF Aims to Resuscitate Chess this Year

      BCF Aims to Resuscitate Chess this Year

      Tebogo’s Move to US on Hold

      “Don’t Panic,” Tebogo is advised as He Transits to Senior Level

      NSAs decry Absence of School Sports 

      NSAs decry Absence of School Sports 

      BCF fails to send Team to Continental Schools Chess Champs

      BCF fails to send Team to Continental Schools Chess Champs

      Trending Tags

      • Subscribe
      No Result
      View All Result
      The Business Weekly & Review
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Economy

      Stagflation exposes Botswana’s investment status

      The elephant in the room is firms resorting to retrenchments as a saving grace.

      mm by Kitso Dickson
      March 2, 2022
      in Economy, News
      0
      Stagflation exposes Botswana’s investment status

      GABORONE 10 March 2021, Botswana president Dr Mokgweetsi E.K Masisi delivers his speech on the occasion of the Africa Private Sector Summit 2021 held under the theme “Doing business under the Africa” on 10 March 2021. Masisi joins the summit virtually with the Minister of Trade and Investment Peggy Serame. Masisi addresses the media after delivering the speech. Masisi (L) and Serame (R) addressing the media. (Pic: MONIRUL BHUIYAN/PRESS PHOTO)

      0
      SHARES
      2.2k
      VIEWS
      Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

      Stagflation is a theme that had been building traction towards the end of last year. The narrative considered three common indicators: economic growth, inflation and unemployment. Often, economists expect inflation and unemployment to be growing in opposite directions. This is because in a high inflationary environment, there should be increased consumer activity, suggesting the economy being near full production.

      But such is not the case for Botswana, the reason being that the inflation is not being driven by demand but is supply side – taxes, levies and tariffs increased at the start of Q2 2021. Rubbing salt into the wounds of Batswana were the fuel price increases, the last of which was effected on 20 December 2021, coupled with a P1.00 increase in public transport fares for both taxis and minibuses. These took January inflation to 10.6 percent.

      Source: Statistics Botswana

      The immediate backdrop is that inflation is worryingly high, having risen progressively since the second quarter of 2021, Moses Pelaelo, the Governor of the Bank of Botswana said this week during the launch of the Monetary Policy Statement. At this level, he said “there is a risk of self-fulfilling expectations of sustained high inflation as manifested in inflation-indexed contract price adjustments, agitation for higher transport fares, negotiations for wage and salary increases, a rise in house rentals and general price increases for goods and services”.

      Amidst this, Botswana has a real wage growth which contradicts why inflation should be increasing. Government expenditure increased marginally by 0.1 percent in the first 11 months of 2021 compared to a decrease of 0.8 percent in the prior year, according to Pelaelo. “Within this, public sector personal emoluments rose by 4.4 percent,” he noted, adding that demand conditions as indicated by a negative output gap (the difference between actual and potential output for the economy) were modest and non-inflationary.

      CPI January 2022
      Source: Statistics Botswana

      The elephant in the room is rising unemployment as businesses struggled and used retrenchments as a saving grace. Recent labour force survey results by Statistics Botswana indicated that the unemployment rate in Q4 2021 was 26 percent from 24.5 percent, which Pelaelo says affirms the “below-trend output growth”. Botswana’s fast recovery for the year in 2021, which Econsult economists expect will outpace projections by the finance ministry and the IMF, is attributed to base effects. Growth was coming from a lower base as in the past year GDP growth was negative. Against this background, some economists anticipate that growth will slow down this year. Pelaelo lent credence to this: “The domestic economy is forecast to grow by 4.3 percent in 2022, driven mainly by the continuing recovery of mining activity and improvement in global output,” he said.

      Pelaelo’s point of improving mining activity adds to entrenched concerns by observers that without diversification, there is limited economic growth for Botswana, given that the economy is centred on mining. “Concerns over whether or not the improved economic output will translate into job creation and therefore a reduction in unemployment still remain,” Sethunya Kegakgametse and Kitso Mokhurutshe, economists at Econsult, said in a quarterly report recently released. Mining is a significant revenue earner and allows the government the ability to roll out some initiatives, the success of which some argue can lead to a stagflationary environment.

      Although economic recovery has been broad-based, Kegakgametse and Mokhurutshe observed that its main driver has been diamond mining and trading sectors which are capital intensive and have a low labour share of income. Statistics Botswana shows that the Wholesale & Retail Trade sector remains the highest employment sector in Botswana, constituting 18.7 percent of the total employed persons. It is followed by Public Administration and Educational sectors with 15.8 and 10.6 percent respectively. Mining and quarrying is listed among the least employers.

      Adding to these problems is that although the inflation is pushed by costs, Botswana is in an environment where interest rates are expected to increase, given that the way it is increasing it is a growth inhibitor.

      Headline inflation vs. bank rate,
      Source: RMB Markets, Statistics Botswana, Bank of Botswana

      In his speech this week, Pelaelo was quick to point out that the risks to the inflation outcome are skewed to the upside. This, he said, relates to second round effects and expectations: a larger increase in commodity prices (especially energy prices) than currently incorporated in the inflation forecast, particularly emanating from current geopolitical tensions as the talk of a possible war in Europe intensifies, short-term unintended consequences of import restrictions, and persistence of supply and logistical constraints due to lags in production.

      “Against these are the downside risks to inflation which include, weaker economic activity than projected, re- emergence of virulent COVID-19 variants (winter months are coming) and resultant restrictions on economic activity, and lower international commodity prices than currently projected,” he said. Without the additional factor of rate hikes, economists who spoke to this publication fear that it would lead to a stagflation environment. Rate hike is even more significant for Botswana because the expectation is that growth will be at a lower rate than last year.

      The strange thing is that while the central bank is expected to increase rates to arrest the inflation, a rate hike is usually done against the backdrop of demand side inflation, which is not the case for Botswana. This is because the economy will be overheating and needs to be cooled down. On top of that, observers argue that a rate hike needs to be looked at from an investment point of view. Inflation has skyrocketed to 10.6 percent while the bank rate is at 3.75 percent. This means the real interest rate is widening. The question is, why would anyone invest in Botswana when they can get a better rate of return in other places?

      As Pelaelo already mentioned, some central banks, particularly in emerging market economies, increased their policy rates in 2021 responding to the rising inflationary pressures. Moreover, he noted that some central banks in the advanced economies signalled that they would tighten policy rates, going forward, to control inflation and, in some cases, taper the asset purchase programmes introduced in 2020 to support the financial sector. Closer to home, he turned his mind to the South African Reserve Bank which increased the repo rate by 25 basis points to 3.75 percent in 2021 and by another 25 basis points to 4 percent in January this year to counter perceived upside risks to the inflation outlook. The Bank of Namibia also opted to increase interest rates by 25 basis points to 4.0 percent.

      Critics argue that it would not make sense why Botswana would stay widening in terms of real interest rate differentials while everyone is trying to narrow. It is all these factors which economists argue might force the Bank of Botswana to start to act soon. But from a central bank’s stand point, they have been hanging back because they think it is transitory. Even though their outlook has increased, economists’ view is that they are waiting to see the dip and gather how much they actually need to respond before they start hiking.

       

       

       

      Tags: Bank of BotswanaBank of NamibiaCOVID-19EconsultGDPIMFInflationKitso MokhurutsheMoses PelaeloSethunya KegakgametseSouth African Reserve BankStagflationStatistics Botswanaunemployment

      Navigation

      • Home
      • News
      • Economy
      • Columns
      • Companies & Markets
      • In Business With
      • Lifestyle
        • Motoring
      • Sports
      • Subscribe

      Recent News

      • Debswana sponsors BFA’s National First Division League with P3.9m 
      • January 27 2023 Edition
      • Proposed Law to Tighten the Screws on Banks 
      • David Van Niekerk appeals after losing interdiction case 
      • Ditlhokwe Tipped to Excel at Kaizer Chiefs

      Site

      • About
      • Advertise
      • Privacy Policy
      • Cookie Policy
      • Contact
      • Subscribe
      • E-edition

      © 2021 The Business Weekly & Review. All Rights Reserved.

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • News
      • Economy
      • Columns
      • Companies & Markets
      • In Business With
      • Lifestyle
        • Motoring
      • Sports
      • Subscribe

      © 2021 The Business Weekly & Review. All Rights Reserved.

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password? Sign Up

      Create New Account!

      Fill the forms below to register

      All fields are required. Log In

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
      Are you sure want to unlock this post?
      Unlock left : 0
      Are you sure want to cancel subscription?